August 06, 2024
Renting vs. Purchasing an Instrument
It’s a question that confronts every parent of a band or orchestra student: Is it better to rent or buy an instrument? More questions follow: Will your child stick with it for a while? Will they want to switch instruments at some point? Will you need to start with a smaller instrument and upgrade as they grow? And last but not certainly least — what will it cost?
To make the right decisions, you need to consider all of the factors. Renting and purchasing an instrument each come with different advantages, costs and responsibilities, and there’s no one right answer for everybody. In this article, we’ll help you learn about the pros and cons of both renting and purchasing, so you can get the best value possible.
Why rent an instrument?
Most band and orchestra students begin with a rental instrument, for a variety of reasons. For starters, new students (especially younger ones) don’t always stick with their original instrument. After a few weeks or months of band, orchestra or lessons, students might want to switch from saxophone to clarinet, violin to cello, or even decide to quit band or orchestra. Advancing students might want to step up to a higher-quality instrument.
“We strive to make the rental process as easy as possible.”
Renting an instrument offers several obvious benefits for parents (and adult students), starting with the cost: Paying a little each month is much more accessible than an up-front purchase. Renting also offers the freedom to try out an instrument before committing to it, and players can always start with a student model while they save up for an intermediate or professional instrument.
There are a lot of perks to renting a musical instrument, but there are a few stipulations, too. For instance, experienced musicians will sometimes make modifications to their instrument to match their specific playing style, and that customization should be reserved for an instrument they own. And while renting is often ideal in the short term, it can end up costing more than buying if your child is committed to music for the long haul.
Why rent with Music & Arts?
We strive to make the rental process as easy as possible. To start, renting online couldn’t be simpler. Identify your school and your child’s instrument and you’ll be on your way: We’ve worked with your school program’s music educator to pre-load the instruments, supplies and books that are required for your child’s class — plus, direct shipping to your home is free. In addition, our Educational Representatives work closely with educators across the country to provide free delivery to your school. If you have any questions or need assistance at any time, simply visit one of our 500 brick-and-mortar rental locations — including our stores and affiliates — across the U.S.
Music & Arts offers educator-approved rental instruments from trusted brands such as Yamaha, Conn Selmer, Buffet Crampon, Jupiter, Giardinelli and Strobel. Flexible payment options ensure that a rental will fit your family’s budget, and rental payments can count toward an instrument purchase.
“Flexible payment options allow rental payments to count toward an instrument purchase.”
If your child changes their mind, no problem: Returns and exchanges are free, and upgrades are a breeze. We also offer affordable repair and maintenance coverage, provided by industry-leading technicians for all our instrument rentals. Between our vast repairs network and convenient drop-off, pick-up and delivery options, your child will never miss a rehearsal or lesson. And if they need a working instrument right away, we’ll simply exchange their instrument for another that’s ready to go.
Why buy an instrument?
Although most students start with a rental, many end up purchasing an instrument once they’ve been playing for a while. The obvious advantage of buying is simple value: For one up-front payment or a few installments, you own the instrument outright. If the student is truly passionate about music, this investment is well worth it in the long run. Buying also gives you many more options when it comes to choosing specific brands, finishes and features, as well as specialized instruments or those geared toward intermediate and professional players.
“Buying comes with more responsibility than renting, and you’ll need to pay out-of-pocket for repairs.”
For younger students, owning an instrument can bring a sense of pride and reinforce non-musical skills like maintenance. Older students often develop a bond with their instrument over time, becoming better players as their instrument’s unique sound and feel become second nature. And when your child owns an instrument, they can have fun decorating and personalizing their instrument case.
Buying an instrument has clear advantages, but it’s a big decision and not one you should rush into until you’ve considered all the factors. First, buying comes with more responsibility than renting, and you’ll need to pay out-of-pocket for repairs (or sign up for Music & Arts’ Instrument Maintenance Agreement when you make your purchase). You’ll also need to make sure the instrument you choose is appropriate for your child’s school band or orchestra.
Why buy from Music & Arts?
Music & Arts offers the industry’s largest selection of band and orchestra instruments, including high-end models that aren’t available to rent. Whether you’re looking for an elegant black-lacquer saxophone or an acoustic viola with a built-in pickup, you’re sure to find the perfect instrument to purchase in our online store. To help you narrow down the many options, we’ve even divided our store into beginner, intermediate and pro sections. And of course you can always visit one of Music & Arts’ 250+ retail stores to try out instruments in-person.
We know that buying an instrument is a big commitment, and we’re committed to offering the best possible value. We’ll match prices with other retailers to get you the guaranteed lowest price, and our financing options allow you to spread the cost out over 24 months with no interest. And for peace of mind, you can protect your investment with an Instrument Maintenance Agreement.
How to Choose Between Renting & Buying an Instrument
We get it — we’ve given you a lot to think about. If you still can’t decide between renting and purchasing an instrument, here’s a quick overview of the main pros and cons of each.
| Renting | Purchasing | |
|---|---|---|
| Advantages | - Short-term affordability - No pressure to commit | - Value - Selection - Personalization |
| Drawbacks | - Smaller selection - Higher long-term cost | - Higher up-front cost - More responsibility |
| Best for | New students and younger musicians | Older students and experienced musicians |
| What Music & Arts offers | - Educator-approved instruments, plus free direct shipping - Rental payments can be credited toward a purchase - Free exchanges and returns - Industry-leading School Services - Affordable maintenance and repair plans | - Largest selection of name-brand instruments in all price ranges - Price match - Financing plans - 250+ retail stores - Affordable maintenance and repair plans |
Questions to Think About Before Renting or Buying an Instrument
If you’re still unsure whether renting or buying is the right choice, asking yourself a few key questions can help clarify your decision. Consider your child’s musical goals, your budget and how flexible you want the arrangement to be.
-
Commitment Level
- How long do I expect my child to stick with this instrument?
- Is this their first time playing or have they demonstrated long-term interest?
-
Flexibility Needs
- Will they want to switch instruments in the future?
- Do I need the option to upgrade or exchange easily?
-
Budget Considerations
- Can I afford a onetime purchase or is a monthly rental more manageable?
- Am I looking for a short-term solution or a long-term investment?
-
Maintenance & Responsibility
- Am I OK with paying out of pocket for repairs and upkeep?
- Would I prefer a plan that includes maintenance coverage?
-
School & Program Requirements
- Does my child’s school recommend renting or buying?
- Are there specific brands/models required by the band director?
Taking time to reflect on these questions will help you make a confident, informed decision that best supports your child.
Making the Right Choice for Your Musical Journey
In the end, every student or beginning musician is unique, with their own needs. For those interested in music but unsure whether it will be a lifelong pursuit, renting is a great option, providing a high-quality instrument without a long-term commitment. For players who are already dedicated, buying may be more cost-effective.
Whether you choose to rent or buy, Music & Arts is your best option, offering educator-approved instruments from top brands at prices that fit your family’s budget. Your decision will be backed by industry-leading support, including our expert repair network and the friendly, knowledgeable service you’ll find at any of our 250+ neighborhood stores. Explore our site or visit your nearest location today — we can’t wait to see you!
Ready to find the perfect instrument for your music education? Check out our rentals page, browse our online store or stop in to one of our many locations today!
